Management of Sampling Uncertainty Using Conservative Estimate of Probability in Bayesian Network

Author(s):  
Sangjune Bae ◽  
Nam H. Kim ◽  
Seung-gyo Jang

Since the safety of a system is often assessed by the probability of failure, it is crucial to calculate the probability accurately in order to achieve the target safety. Despite such importance, calculating the precise probability is not a trivial task due to the inherent aleatory variability and epistemic uncertainty. Therefore the safety is assessed by a conservative estimate of the probability rather than using a single value of the probability. In general, there are two ways to achieve the target probability: Shifting the probability or reducing the uncertainty. In this paper, among various sources of epistemic uncertainty, the uncertainty quantification error from sampling is considered to calculate the conservative estimate of a system probability of failure. To quantify and shape the epistemic uncertainty, Bayesian network is utilized for constituting the relationship between the system probability and component probabilities, while global sensitivity analysis is employed to connect the variance in the probabilities in system level with that in the component level. Based on this, local sensitivity of the conservative estimate with respect to a design change in a component is derived and approximated for a simple numerical calculation using Bayesian network and global sensitivity analysis. This is to show how a design can meet the probabilistic criteria considering propagated uncertainty when the design changes.

AIAA Journal ◽  
2017 ◽  
Vol 55 (11) ◽  
pp. 3916-3924 ◽  
Author(s):  
Sangjune Bae ◽  
Nam H. Kim ◽  
Chanyoung Park ◽  
Zaeill Kim

Author(s):  
Chenzhao Li ◽  
Sankaran Mahadevan

In a Bayesian network, how a node of interest is affected by the observation of another node is of interest in both forward propagation and backward inference. The proposed global sensitivity analysis (GSA) for Bayesian network aims to calculate the Sobol’ sensitivity index of a node with respect to the node of interest. The desired GSA for Bayesian network confronts two challenges. First, the computation of the Sobol’ index requires a deterministic function while the Bayesian network is a stochastic model. Second, the computation of the Sobol’ index can be expensive, especially if the model inputs are correlated, which is common in a Bayesian network. To solve the first challenge, this paper uses the auxiliary variable method to convert the path between two nodes in the Bayesian network to a deterministic function, thus making the Sobol’ index computation feasible in a Bayesian network. To solve the second challenge, this paper proposes an efficient algorithm to directly estimate the first-order Sobol’ index from Monte Carlo samples of the prior distribution of the Bayesian network, so that the proposed GSA for Bayesian network is computationally affordable. Before the updating, the proposed algorithm can predict the uncertainty reduction of the node of interest purely using the prior distribution samples, thus providing quantitative guidance for effective observation and updating.


Author(s):  
Zdeněk Kala

The probability of failure of a load bearing steel member is investigated using a new type of global sensitivity analysis subordinated to contrasts. The main objective of the probability-oriented sensitivity analysis is structural reliability. The structural reliability methodology uses random variables as inputs. The subject of interest is the identification of those random variables that are most important when the limit state of a steel bridge member is reached. The limit state is defined by the occurrence of brittle fracture, which results from stress changes caused by multiple repeated loads. The propagation of a single-edge crack from initial to critical size is analysed using linear fracture mechanics. The failure probability and sensitivity indices are calculated using sampling-based methods. The sensitivity indices are estimated using double-nested-loop simulation of the Latin Hypercube Sampling method. New findings indicate that interaction effects among input variables strongly influence the probability of failure especially at the beginning of the operating period.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document