A Single-Stage Gradient-Based Approach for Solving the Joint Product Family Platform Selection and Design Problem Using Decomposition

Author(s):  
Aida Khajavirad ◽  
Jeremy J. Michalek

A core challenge in product family optimization is to develop a single-stage approach that can optimally select the set of variables to be shared in the platform(s) while simultaneously designing the platform(s) and variants within an algorithm that is efficient and scalable. However, solving the joint product family platform selection and design problem involves significant complexity and computational cost, so most prior methods have narrowed the scope by treating the platform as fixed or have relied on stochastic algorithms or heuristic two-stage approaches that may sacrifice optimality. In this paper, we propose a single-stage approach for optimizing the joint problem using gradient-based methods. The combinatorial platform-selection variables are relaxed to the continuous space by applying the commonality index and consistency relaxation function introduced in a companion paper. In order to improve scalability properties, we exploit the structure of the product family problem and decompose the joint product family optimization problem into a two-level optimization problem using analytical target cascading so that the system-level problem determines the optimal platform configuration while each subsystem optimizes a single product in the family. Finally, we demonstrate the approach through optimization of a family of ten bathroom scales; Results indicate encouraging success with scalability and computational expense.

2008 ◽  
Vol 130 (7) ◽  
Author(s):  
Aida Khajavirad ◽  
Jeremy J. Michalek

A core challenge in product family optimization is to jointly determine (1) the optimal selection of components to be shared across product variants and (2) the optimal values for design variables that define those components. Each of these subtasks depends on the other; however, due to the combinatorial nature and high computational cost of the joint problem, prior methods have forgone optimality of the full problem by fixing the platform a priori, restricting the platform configuration to all-or-none component sharing, or optimizing the joint problem in multiple stages. In this paper, we address these restrictions by (1) introducing an extended metric to account for generalized commonality, (2) relaxing the metric to the continuous space to enable gradient-based optimization, and (3) proposing a decomposed single-stage method for optimizing the joint problem. The approach is demonstrated on a family of ten bathroom scales. Results indicate that generalized commonality dramatically improves the quality of optimal solutions, and the decomposed single-stage approach offers substantial improvement in scalability and tractability of the joint problem, providing a practical tool for optimizing families consisting of many variants.


Author(s):  
Aida Khajavirad ◽  
Jeremy J. Michalek

One critical aim of product family design is to offer distinct variants that attract a variety of market segments while maximizing the number of common parts to reduce manufacturing cost. Several indices have been developed for measuring the degree of commonality in existing product lines to compare product families or assess improvement of a redesign. In the product family optimization literature, commonality metrics are used to define the multi-objective tradeoff between commonality and individual variant performance. These metrics for optimization differ from indices in the first group: While the optimization metrics provide desirable computational properties, they generally lack the desirable properties of indices intended to act as appropriate proxies for the benefits of commonality, such as reduced tooling and supply chain costs. In this paper, we propose a method for computing the commonality index introduced by Martin and Ishii using the available input data for any product family without predefined configuration. The proposed method for computing the commonality index, which was originally defined for binary formulations (common / not common), is relaxed to the continuous space in order to solve the discrete problem with a series of continuous relaxations, and the effect of relaxation on the metric behavior is investigated. Several relaxation formulations are examined, and a new function with desirable properties is introduced and compared with prior formulations. The new properties of the proposed metric enable development of an efficient and robust single-stage gradient-based optimization of the joint product family platform selection and design problem, which is examined in a companion paper.


Author(s):  
Xiaokai Chen ◽  
Chenyu Wang ◽  
Guobiao Shi ◽  
Mingkai Zeng

In order to improve the performance of automotive product platforms and product families while keeping high development efficiency, a product family optimization design method that combines shared variable decision-making and multidisciplinary design optimization (MDO) is proposed. First, the basic concepts related to product family design optimization were clarified. Then, the mathematical description and MDO model of the product family optimization problem were established, and the improved product family design process was given. Finally, for the chassis product family optimization problem of an automotive product platform, the effectiveness of the proposed optimization method, and design process were exemplified. The results show that the collaboratively optimized product family can effectively handle the coordination between multiple products and multiple targets, compared to Non-platform development, it can maximize the generalization rate of vehicle parts and components under the premise of ensuring key performance, and give full play to the advantages of product platforms.


Author(s):  
Brian C. Williams ◽  
Jonathan Cagan

Abstract Activity analysis is introduced as a means to strategically cut away subspaces of a design problem that can quickly be ruled out as suboptimal. This results in focused regions of the space in which additional symbolic or numerical analysis can take place. Activity analysis is derived from a qualitative abstraction of the Karush-Kuhn-Tucker conditions of optimality, used to partition an optimization problem into regions which are nonstationary and qualitatively stationary (qstationary). Activity analysis draws from the fields of gradient-based optimization, conflict-based approaches of combinatorial satisficing search, and monotonicity analysis.


Author(s):  
Hampus Hederberg ◽  
Carl-Johan Thore

AbstractDesigns obtained with topology optimization (TO) are usually not safe against damage. In this paper, density-based TO is combined with a moving morphable component (MMC) representation of structural damage in an optimization problem for fail-safe designs. Damage is inflicted on the structure by an MMC which removes material, and the goal of the design problem is to minimize the compliance for the worst possible damage. The worst damage is sought by optimizing the position of the MMC to maximize the compliance for a given design. This non-convex problem is treated using a gradient-based solver by initializing the MMC at multiple locations and taking the maximum of the compliances obtained. The use of MMCs to model damage gives a finite element-mesh-independent method, and by allowing the components to move rather than remain at fixed locations, more robust structures are obtained. Numerical examples show that the proposed method can produce fail-safe designs with reasonable computational cost.


2007 ◽  
Vol 51 (1-2) ◽  
pp. 43
Author(s):  
Balázs Polgár ◽  
Endre Selényi
Keyword(s):  

Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document