Improving Steady Computational Fluid Dynamics to Capture the Effects of Radial Mixing in Axial Compressors

2020 ◽  
Vol 142 (9) ◽  
Author(s):  
Lorenzo Cozzi ◽  
Filippo Rubechini ◽  
Andrea Arnone ◽  
Andrea Schneider ◽  
Pio Astrua

Abstract The compressors of power-generation gas turbines (GTs) have a high stage count, blades with low aspect ratios, and large clearances. These features promote strong secondary flows. An important outcome deriving from the convection of intense secondary flows is the enhanced span-wise transport of fluid properties mainly involving the rear stages, generally referred to as “radial mixing.” An incorrect prediction of this key phenomenon may result in inaccurate performance evaluation and could mislead designers. In the rear compressor stages, the stream-wise vorticity associated with tip clearance flows is one of the main drivers of the span-wise transport phenomenon. Limiting it by averaging the flow at row interfaces is the reason why a steady analysis underpredicts radial mixing. To properly forecast the span-wise transport, an unsteady analysis should be adopted. However, this approach has a computational cost not yet suitable for industrial purposes. Currently, only the steady simulation can fit in a lean design chain and any model upgrade improving its radial mixing prediction would be highly beneficial. To attain some progresses in Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes (RANS) model, its lack of convection of stream-wise vorticity must be addressed. This can be done by acting on another mixing driver that is turbulent diffusion; by enhancing turbulent viscosity, one can promote span-wise diffusion, thus improving the radial mixing prediction. In this paper, this strategy to update the RANS model and its application on an existing compressor is presented, together with the model tuning that has been performed using unsteady results as the target.

Author(s):  
Lorenzo Cozzi ◽  
Filippo Rubechini ◽  
Andrea Arnone ◽  
Andrea Schneider ◽  
Pio Astrua

Abstract The axial compressors of power-generation gas turbines have a high stage count, blades with low aspect ratios and relatively large clearances in the rear section. These features promote the development of strong secondary flows. An important outcome deriving from the convection of intense secondary flows is the enhanced span-wise transport of fluid properties mainly involving the rear stages, generally referred to as “radial mixing”. An incorrect prediction of this key phenomenon may result in inaccurate performance evaluation and could mislead the designers during the compressor design phase. As shown in a previous work, in the rear stages of an axial compressor the stream-wise vorticity associated with tip clearance flows is one of the main drivers of the overall span-wise transport phenomenon. Limiting it by circumferentially averaging the flow at row interfaces is the reason why a steady-state analysis strongly under-predicts radial mixing. To properly forecast the span-wise transport within the flow-path, an unsteady analysis should be adopted. However, due to the high blade count, this approach has a computational cost not yet suitable for industrial purposes. Currently, only the steady-state full-compressor simulation can fit in a lean industrial design chain and any model upgrade improving its radial mixing prediction would be highly beneficial for the daily design practice. To attain some progresses in RANS model, its inherent lack of convection of stream-wise vorticity must be addressed. This can be done by acting on another mixing driver, able to provide the same outcome, that is turbulent diffusion. In particular, by enhancing turbulent viscosity one can promote span-wise diffusion, thus improving the radial mixing prediction of the steady approach. In this paper, this strategy to update the RANS model and its application in simulations on a compressor of the Ansaldo Energia fleet is presented, together with the model tuning that has been performed using the results of unsteady simulations as the target.


Author(s):  
D Borello ◽  
G Delibra ◽  
K Hanjalić ◽  
F Rispoli

This paper reports on the application of unsteady Reynolds averaged Navier—Stokes (U-RANS) and hybrid large-eddy simulation (LES)/Reynolds averaged Navier—Stokes (RANS) methods to predict flows in compressor cascades using an affordable computational mesh. Both approaches use the ζ— f elliptic relaxation eddy-viscosity model, which for U-RANS prevails throughout the flow, whereas for the hybrid the U-RANS is active only in the near-wall region, coupled with the dynamic LES in the rest of the flow. In this ‘seamless’ coupling the dissipation rate in the k-equation is multiplied by a grid-detection function in terms of the ratio of the RANS and LES length scales. The potential of both approaches was tested in several benchmark flows showing satisfactory agreement with the available experimental results. The flow pattern through the tip clearance in a low-speed linear cascade shows close similarity with experimental evidence, indicating that both approaches can reproduce qualitatively the tip leakage and tip separation vortices with a relatively coarse computational mesh. The hybrid method, however, showed to be superior in capturing the evolution of vortical structures and related unsteadiness in the hub and wake regions.


Author(s):  
Lorenzo Cozzi ◽  
Filippo Rubechini ◽  
Andrea Arnone ◽  
Savino Depalo ◽  
Pio Astrua ◽  
...  

Abstract The overall fraction of the power produced by renewable sources in the energy market has significantly increased in recent years. The power output of most of these clean sources is intrinsically variable. At present day and most likely in the upcoming future, due to the lack of inexpensive and reliable large energy storage systems, conventional power plants burning fossil fuels will still be part of the energy horizon. In particular, power generators able to promptly support the grid stability, such as gas turbines, will retain a strategic role. This new energy scenario is pushing gas turbine producers to improve the flexibility of their turbomachines, increasing the need for reliable numerical tools adopted to design and validate the new products also in operating conditions far from the nominal one. Especially when dealing with axial compressors, i.e. machines experiencing intense adverse pressure gradients, complex flow structures and severe secondary flows, CFD modelling of offdesign operation can be a real challenge. In this work, a state-of-the art CFD framework for RANS analysis of axial compressors is presented. The various aspects involved in the whole setup are discussed, including boundary conditions, meshing strategies, mixing planes modelling, tip clearance treatment, shroud leakages and turbulence modelling. Some experiences about the choice of these aspects are provided, derived from a long-date practice on this kind of turbomachines. Numerical results are reported for different full-scale compressors of the Ansaldo Energia fleet, covering a wide range of operating conditions. Furthermore, details about the capability of the setup to predict compressor performance and surge-margin have been added to the work. In particular, the setup surge-margin prediction has been evaluated in an operating condition in which the turbomachine experiences experimental stall. Finally, thanks to several on-field data available at different corrected speeds for operating conditions ranging from minimum to full load, a comprehensive validation of the presented numerical framework is also included in the paper.


Author(s):  
J. Luo ◽  
B. Lakshminarayana

The 3-D viscous flowfield in the rotor passage of a single-stage turbine, including the tip-leakage flow, is computed using a Navier-Stokes procedure. A grid-generation code has been developed to obtain embedded H grids inside the rotor tip gap. The blade tip geometry is accurately modeled without any “pinching”. Chien’s low-Reynolds-number k-ε model is employed for turbulence closure. Both the mean-flow and turbulence transport equations are integrated in time using a four-stage Runge-Kutta scheme. The computational results for the entire turbine rotor flow, particularly the tip-leakage flow and the secondary flows, are interpreted and compared with available data. The predictions for major features of the flowfield are found to be in good agreement with the data. Complicated interactions between the tip-clearance flows and the secondary flows are examined in detail. The effects of endwall rotation on the development and interaction of secondary and tip-leakage vortices are also analyzed.


1991 ◽  
Vol 113 (2) ◽  
pp. 241-250 ◽  
Author(s):  
C. Hah ◽  
A. J. Wennerstrom

The concept of swept blades for a transonic or supersonic compressor was reconsidered by Wennerstrom in the early 1980s. Several transonic rotors designed with swept blades have shown very good aerodynamic efficiency. The improved performance of the rotor is believed to be due to reduced shock strength near the shroud and better distribution of secondary flows. A three-dimensional flowfield inside a transonic rotor with swept blades is analyzed in detail experimentally and numerically. A Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes equation is solved for the flow inside the rotor. The numerical solution is based on a high-order upwinding relaxation scheme, and a two-equation turbulence model with a low Reynolds number modification is used for the turbulence modeling. To predict flows near the shroud properly, the tip-clearance flow also must be properly calculated. The numerical results at three different operating conditions agree well with the available experimental data and reveal various interesting aspects of shock structure inside the rotor.


Author(s):  
C. Hah ◽  
A. J. Wennerstrom

The concept of swept blades for a transonic or supersonic compressor was reconsidered by Wennerstrom in the early 1980s. Several transonic rotors designed with swept blades have shown very good aerodynamic efficiency. The improved performance of the rotor is believed to be due to reduced shock strength near the shroud and better distribution of secondary flows. A three-dimensional flowfield inside a transonic rotor with swept blades is analyzed in detail experimentally and numerically. A Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes equation is solved for the flow inside the rotor. The numerical solution is based on a high-order upwinding relaxation scheme, and a two-equation turbulence model with a low Reynolds number modification is used for the turbulence modeling. To properly predict flows near the shroud, the tip-clearance flow also must be properly calculated. The numerical results at three different operating conditions agree well with the available experimental data and reveal various interesting aspects of shock structure inside the rotor.


2019 ◽  
Vol 141 (3) ◽  
Author(s):  
Lorenzo Cozzi ◽  
Filippo Rubechini ◽  
Matteo Giovannini ◽  
Michele Marconcini ◽  
Andrea Arnone ◽  
...  

The current industrial standard for numerical simulations of axial compressors is the steady Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes (RANS) approach. Besides the well-known limitations of mixing planes, namely their inherent inability to capture the potential interaction and the wakes from the upstream blades, there is another flow feature which is lost, and which is a major accountable for the radial mixing: the transport of streamwise vorticity. Streamwise vorticity is generated for various reasons, mainly associated with secondary and tip-clearance flows. A strong link exists between the strain field associated with the vortices and the mixing augmentation: the strain field increases both the area available for mixing and the local gradients in fluid properties, which provide the driving potential for the mixing. In the rear compressor stages, due to high clearances and low aspect ratios, only accounting for the development of secondary and clearance flow structures, it is possible to properly predict the spanwise mixing. In this work, the results of steady and unsteady simulations on a heavy-duty axial compressor are compared with experimental data. Adopting an unsteady framework, the enhanced mixing in the rear stages is properly captured, in remarkable agreement with experimental distributions. On the contrary, steady analyses strongly underestimate the radial transport. It is inferred that the streamwise vorticity associated with clearance flows is a major driver of radial mixing, and restraining it by pitch-averaging the flow at mixing planes is the reason why the steady approach cannot predict the radial transport in the rear part of the compressor.


Author(s):  
Reinhard Mönig ◽  
Frank Mildner ◽  
Ralf Röper

During the last few decades extremely powerful Quasi-3D codes and fully 3D Navier-Stokes solvers have been developed and successfully utilized in the design process and optimization of multistage axial-flow compressors. However, most of these methods proved to be difficult in handling and extremely time consuming. Due to these disadvantages, the primary stage design and stage matching as well as the off-design analysis is nowadays still based on fast 2D methods incorporating loss-, deviation- and end wall modeling. Only the detailed 3D optimization is normally performed by means of advanced 3D methods. In this paper a fast and efficient 2D calculation method is presented, which already in the initial design phase of multistage axial flow compressors considers the influence of hub leakage flows, tip clearance effects and other end wall flow phenomena. The method is generally based on the fundamental approach by Howard and Gallimore (1992). In order to allow a more accurate prediction of skewed and non-developed boundary layers in turbomachines an improved theoretical approach was implemented. Particularly the splitting of the boundary layers into an axial and tangential component proved to be necessary in order to account for the change between rotating and stationary end walls. Additionally, a new approach is used for the prediction of the viscous end wall zones including hub leakage effects and strongly skewed boundary layers. As a result, empirical correlations for secondary flow effects are no longer required. The results of the improved method are compared with conventional 2D-results including 3D loss- and deviation-models, with, experimental data of a 3-stage research compressor of the Institute for Jet Propulsion and Turbomachinery of the Technical University of Aachen and with 3D Navier-Stokes solutions of the V84.3A compressor and of a multi-stage Siemens research compressor. The results obtained using the new method show a remarkable improvement in comparison with conventional 2D-methods. Due to the high quality and the extremely short computation time the new method allows an overall viscous design of multistage compressors for heavy duty gas turbines and aeroengine applications.


Author(s):  
M. Cochet ◽  
W. Colban ◽  
M. Gritsch ◽  
S. Naik ◽  
M. Schnieder

Low emission requirements for heavy-duty gas turbines can be achieved with flat combustor temperature profiles, reducing the combustor peak temperature. As a result, the heat load on the first stage heat shield above the first stage blade increases. High lift airfoils cause increased thermal loading on the heat shield above the blade tip and impact the unavoidable secondary flows, including complex vortex flows. Cascade tests have been performed on a blade with a generic high lift profile and the results on the heat shield are presented. A transient thermochromic liquid crystal measurement technique was used to obtain heat transfer coefficients on the heat shield surface. Several variations of blade tip clearance were investigated, and the impact on heat transfer coefficients is shown. Computational fluid dynamics predictions are compared to the experimental data to interpret the data and validate the CFD.


Author(s):  
Feng Shen ◽  
Lei Yu ◽  
William T. Cousins ◽  
Vishnu Sishtla ◽  
Om P. Sharma

The inlet pipe to a centrifugal compressor in a water-cooled chiller can cause complexities in designing a compact unit. Flow distortion caused by the inlet pipe shape and non-uniformity of the flow from the evaporator can affect the compressor performance. Inlet guide vanes (IGVs) used for capacity control may help reduce the distortion by forcing a redistribution of the flow. However, the guide vanes themselves result in increased losses and can introduce flow distortion due to the clearance between the movable vane and stationary housing. In this effort, the influence of the flow distortion on the impeller performance and the losses caused by IGVs were investigated using a commercial code dealing with real gas. The CFD model was first verified by comparison to test data. Further investigation showed that the hub-to-shroud flow distortion, especially shroud side distortion, has a major effect on stage performance. IGVs are necessary for straightening the incoming flow to benefit stall margin but generate high losses themselves. The tip clearance of the IGV decreases the deswirl capability and introduces additional local separation loss. Distortion intensity was calculated according to ARP-1420 methods to justify the usage of the mixing plane in the CFD modeling. The extent of distortion indicated that the steady simulation served as a preferable choice for balancing computational cost & prediction accuracy.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document