An Analysis of Common Drill Stem Vibration Models

2017 ◽  
Vol 140 (1) ◽  
Author(s):  
Mohammed F. Al Dushaishi ◽  
Runar Nygaard ◽  
Daniel S. Stutts

Excessive drill stem (DS) vibration while rotary drilling of oil and gas wells causes damages to drill bits and bottom hole assemblies (BHAs). In an attempt to mitigate DS vibrations, theoretical modeling of DS dynamics is used to predict severe vibration conditions. To construct the model, decisions have to be made on which beam theory to be used, how to implement forces acting on the DS, and the geometry of the DS. The objective of this paper is to emphasize the effect of these assumptions on DS vibration behavior under different, yet realistic, drilling conditions. The nonlinear equations of motion were obtained using Hamilton's principle and discretized using the finite element method. The finite element formulations were verified with uncoupled analytical models. A parametric study showed that increasing the weight on bit (WOB) and the drill pipe (DP) length clearly decreases the DS frequencies. However, extending the drill collar length does not reveal a clear trend in the resulting lateral vibration frequency behavior. At normal operating conditions with a low operating rotational speed, less than 80 RPM, the nonlinear Euler–Bernoulli and Timoshenko models give comparable results. At higher rotational speeds, the models deliver different outcomes. Considering only the BHA overestimates the DS critical operating speed; thus, the entire DS has to be considered to determine the critical RPM values to be avoided.

Author(s):  
Scott D. Ironside ◽  
L. Blair Carroll

Enbridge Pipelines Inc. operates the world’s longest and most complex liquids pipeline network. As part of Enbridge’s Integrity Management Program In-Line Inspections have been and will continue to be conducted on more than 15,000 km of pipeline. The Inspection Programs have included using the most technologically advanced geometry tools in the world to detect geometrical discontinuities such as ovality, dents, and buckles. During the past number of years, Enbridge Pipelines Inc. has been involved in developing a method of evaluating the suitability of dents in pipelines for continued service. The majority of the work involved the development of a method of modeling the stresses within a dent using Finite Element Analysis (FEA). The development and validation of this model was completed by Fleet Technology Limited (FTL) through several projects sponsored by Enbridge, which included field trials and comparisons to previously published data. This model combined with proven fracture mechanics theory provides a method of determining a predicted life of a dent based on either the past or future operating conditions of the pipeline. CSA Standard Z662 – Oil and Gas Pipeline Systems provides criteria for the acceptability of dents for continued service. There have been occurrences, however, where dents that meet the CSA acceptability criteria have experienced failure. The dent model is being used to help define shape characteristics in addition to dent depth, the only shape factor considered by CSA, which contribute to dent failure. The dent model has also been utilized to validate the accuracy of current In-Line Inspection techniques. Typically a dent will lose some of its shape as the overburden is lifted from the pipeline and after the indentor is removed. Often there can be a dramatic “re-rounding” that will occur. The work included comparing the re-rounded dent shapes from a Finite Element model simulating the removal of the constraint on the pipe to the measured dent profile from a mold of the dent taken in the field after it has been excavated. This provided a measure of the accuracy of the tool. This paper will provide an overview of Enbridge’s dent management program, a description of the dent selection process for the excavation program, and a detailed review of the ILI validation work.


Author(s):  
Marco Mariottini ◽  
Nicola Pieroni ◽  
Pietro Bertini ◽  
Beniamino Pacifici ◽  
Alessandro Giorgetti

Abstract In the oil and gas industry, manufacturers are continuously engaged in providing machines with improved performance, reliability and availability. First Stage Bucket is one of the most critical gas turbine components, bearing the brunt of very severe operating conditions in terms of high temperature and stresses; aeromechanic behavior is a key characteristic to be checked, to assure the absence of resonances that can lead to damage. Aim of this paper is to introduce a method for aeromechanical verification applied to the new First Stage Bucket for heavy duty MS5002 gas turbine with integrated cover plates. This target is achieved through a significantly cheaper and streamlined test (a rotating test bench facility, formally Wheel Box Test) in place of a full engine test. Scope of Wheel Box Test is the aeromechanical characterization for both Baseline and New bucket, in addition to the validation of the analytical models developed. Wheel Box Test is focused on the acquisition and visualization of dynamic data, simulating different forcing frequencies, and the measurement of natural frequencies, compared with the expected results. Moreover, a Finite Elements Model (FEM) tuning for frequency prediction is performed. Finally, the characterization of different types of dampers in terms of impact on frequencies and damping effect is carried out. Therefore, in line with response assessment and damping levels estimation, the most suitable damper is selected. The proposed approach could be extended for other machine models and for mechanical audits.


2015 ◽  
Vol 137 (2) ◽  
Author(s):  
Kathira Mongkolcheep ◽  
Annie Ruimi ◽  
Alan Palazzolo

Drillstrings used for oil and gas exploration and extraction consist of a drillpipe (slender columns on the order of 3–5 km long), drill collars (DCs) (thick-walled large-diameter pipes), stabilizers (cylindrical elements with short sections and diameter near that of the borehole), and a rock-cutting tool that uses rotational energy to penetrate the soil. Several types of vibrations ensue from these motions and play a major role in added costs resulting from unforeseen events such as abandoning holes, replacing bits, and fishing severed bottom-hole assemblies (BHAs). It is thus of critical importance to understand, predict, and mitigate the severe vibrations experienced by drillstrings and BHA to optimize drilling time while lowering fuel consumption and related emissions of NOX and/or other pollutants. In this paper, we present a dynamical analysis of the behavior of drillstrings due to the violent lateral vibrations (LVs) DCs may experience as a result of rotating drillstrings. The behavior is represented by a system of two coupled nonlinear ordinary equations that are integrated numerically with a finite element analysis based on Timoshenko beam (TB) formulation combined to a modal condensation technique to reduce the computational time. Various nonlinear dynamical analysis tools, such as frequency spectrum, Poincaré maps, bifurcation diagrams, and Lyapunov exponents (LE), are used to characterizing the response. The DC section between two stabilizers is essentially modeled as a Jeffcott rotor with nonlinearity effects included. The model builds on two earlier models for the finite element formulation and the treatment of chaotic vibrations. Nonlinearity appears in the form of drillstring/borehole contact force, friction, and quadratic damping. The DC flexibility is included to allow investigation of bending modes. The analysis takes into account the length of time to steady state, number of subintervals, presence of rigid body modes, number of finite elements, and modal coordinates. Simulations results indicate that by varying operating conditions, a spectrum of behaviors from periodic to chaotic may be observed.


Author(s):  
F. Yang ◽  
R. Sedaghati ◽  
E. Esmailzadeh

Curved beam-type structures have many applications in engineering area. Due to the initial curvature of the central line, it is complicated to develop and solve the equations of motion by taking into account the extensibility of the curve axis and the influences of the shear deformation and the rotary inertia. In this study the finite element method is utilized to study the curved beam with arbitrary geometry. The curved beam is modeled using the Timoshenko beam theory and the circular ring model. The governing equation of motion is derived using the Extended-Hamilton principle and numerically solved by the finite element method. A parametric sensitive study for the natural frequencies has been performed and compared with those reported in the literature in order to demonstrate the accuracy of the analysis.


Author(s):  
Wolfgang E. Seemann ◽  
Rainer Gausmann

Abstract This paper is dedicated to Prof. Peter Hagedorn, Darmstadt University of Technology, Germany, on the occasion of his 60th birthday. Usually piezoelectric actuators are nowadays simulated with the help of finite element codes. Analytical models are only used for very simple geometries like beams and plates or in those cases where piezoelectric patches are bonded to a beam or plate. Examples can be found in literature. However, it has to be kept in mind that there are still some problems for which standard finite element codes like ANSYS might get difficulties. One such problem is a piezoelectric transformer with an arbitrary load impedance connected to the electrodes of one of the piezoceramics. Such a system is investigated in this paper. To obtain results which are still valid if the diameter of the rod is not small compared to the wave length, a refined rod theory is used which takes into consideration also the inertia effects due to transverse contraction. To derive the equations of motion and the boundary conditions for such a system Hamilton’s principle for electromechanical systems is used. The equations of motion are solved and compared with experimental results. A comparison with results of a finite element analysis is also given for one special case which could be handled by ANSYS.


Author(s):  
Jefferson Lacerda ◽  
Marcelo I. Lourenço ◽  
Theodoro A. Netto

The constant advance of offshore oil and gas production in deeper waters worldwide led to increasing operational loads on flexible pipes, making mechanical failures more susceptible. Therefore, it is important to develop more reliable numerical tools used in the design phase or during the lifetime to ensure the structural integrity of flexible pipes under specific operating conditions. This paper presents a methodology to develop simple finite element models capable of reproducing the behavior of structural layers of flexible pipes under external hydrostatic pressure up to collapse. These models use beam elements and, in multi-layer analyses, include nonlinear contact between layers. Because of the material anisotropy induced by the manufacturing process, an alternative method was carried out to estimate the average stress-strain curves of the metallic layers used in the numerical simulations. The simulations are performed for two different configurations: one where the flexible pipe is composed only of the interlocked armor, and another considering interlocked armor and pressure armor. The adequacy of the numerical models is finally evaluated in light of experimental tests on flexible pipes with nominal internal diameters of 4 and 6 in.


2002 ◽  
Vol 30 (1) ◽  
pp. 19-33 ◽  
Author(s):  
O. A. Olatunbosun ◽  
A. M. Burke

Abstract Finite element analysis presents an opportunity for a detailed study of the dynamic behavior of a rotating tire under real operating conditions providing a better understanding of the influence of tire construction and material detail on tire dynamic behavior in such areas as ride, handling and noise and vibration transmission. Modelling issues that need to be considered include non-linear effects due to tire inflation and hub loading, tire/road contact and time domain solution of the equations of motion. In this paper techniques and strategies for tire rotation modelling are presented and discussed as a guide to the creation of a successful model.


Author(s):  
M Moghaddas ◽  
R Sedaghati ◽  
E Esmailzadeh ◽  
P Khosravi

In this study the finite element formulation for the dynamics of a bridge traversed by moving vehicles is presented. The vehicle including the driver and the passenger is modelled as a half-car planner model with six degree of freedom, travelling on the bridge with constant velocity. The bridge is modelled as a uniform beam with simply supported end conditions that obeys the Timoshenko beam theory. The governing equations of motion are derived using the extended Hamilton principle and then transformed into the finite element format by using the weak-form formulation. The Newmark-β method is utilized to solve the governing equations and the results are compared with those reported in the literature. Furthermore, the maximum values of deflection for the Timoshenko and Euler—Bernoulli beams have been compared. The results illustrated that as the velocity of the vehicle increases, the difference between the maximum beam deflections in the two beam models becomes more significant.


2000 ◽  
Author(s):  
Z. C. Wang ◽  
W. L. Cleghorn ◽  
S. D. Yu

Abstract Free lateral vibration of stepped shafts is investigated in this paper using the Timoshenko beam theory and the finite element method. Beam finite elements having two nodes and 16 degrees of freedom were employed to model flexural vibration of a stepped shaft for a total four field variables — two lateral displacements and two bending angles. Within each uniform segment, the stepped shaft is modeled as a substructure for which a system of equations of motion may be easily formulated using the Galerkin method. The global equations of motion for the entire stepped shaft are subsequently formulated by enforcing the displacement continuity and force equilibrium conditions across the interfaces between two adjacent substructures. The second order governing differential equations for a non self-adjoint dynamic system are then reduced to the equivalent first order differential equations for which eigenvalue problem is formulated and solved using the Matlab® program. Values of natural frequencies are in excellent agreement with those available in the literature. Effects of rotational springs attached to the end of a stepped shaft, used to simulate the non-classical boundary constraints of chuck on a work piece in a typical turning process, are also investigated. The bi-orthogonal conditions for modal vectors, which are useful in chatter analysis during turning processes, are given in this paper.


Actuators ◽  
2018 ◽  
Vol 7 (4) ◽  
pp. 86 ◽  
Author(s):  
Mario Torres Melgarejo ◽  
Maximilian Darnieder ◽  
Sebastian Linß ◽  
Lena Zentner ◽  
Thomas Fröhlich ◽  
...  

Compliant mechanisms based on flexure hinges are widely used in precision engineering applications. Among those are devices such as precision balances and mass comparators with achievable resolutions and uncertainties in the nano-newton range. The exact knowledge of the mechanical properties of notch hinges and their modeling is essential for the design and the goal-oriented adjustment of these devices. It is shown in this article that many analytical equations available in the literature for calculating the bending stiffness of thin semi-circular flexure hinges cause deviations of up to 12% compared to simulation results based on the three-dimensional finite element model for the considered parameter range. A close examination of the stress state within the loaded hinge reveals possible reasons for this deviation. The article explains this phenomenon in detail and shows the limitations of existing analytical models depending on specific geometric ratios. An accurate determination of the bending stiffness of semi-circular flexure hinges in a wide range of geometric parameters without the need for an elaborate finite element analysis is proposed in form of FEM-based correction factors for analytical equations referring to Euler-Bernoulli’s beam theory.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document