Investigation of Flow Aerodynamics for Optimal Fuel Placement and Mixing in the Radial Swirler Slot of a Dry Low Emission Gas Turbine Combustion Chamber

2015 ◽  
Vol 138 (5) ◽  
Author(s):  
Festus Eghe Agbonzikilo ◽  
Ieuan Owen ◽  
Suresh Kumar Sadasivuni ◽  
Ronald A. Bickerton

This paper is concerned with optimizing the fuel–air mixing processes that take place within the radial swirler slot of a dry low emission (DLE) combustion system. The aerodynamics of the flow within the slot is complex and this, together with the placement of the fuel holes with cross injection, controls the mixing of the fuel and air. Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) with the shear stress transport (SST) (k–ω) turbulence model was used for flow and mixing predictions within the radial swirler slot and for conducting a CFD-based design of experiments (DOE) optimization study, in which different parameters related to the fuel injection holes were varied. The optimization study was comprised of 25 orthogonal design configurations in the Taguchi L25 orthogonal array (OA). The test domain for the CFD, and its experimental validation, was a large-scale representation of a swirler slot from the Siemens proprietary DLE combustion system. The DOE study showed that the number of fuel holes, injection hole diameter, and interhole distance are the most influential parameters for determining optimal fuel mixing. Consequently, the optimized mixing configuration obtained from the above study was experimentally tested on an atmospheric test facility. The mixing patterns from experiments at various axial locations across the slot are in good agreement with the mixing predictions from the optimal CFD model. The optimized fuel injection design improved mixing compared with the baseline design by about 60%.

Author(s):  
Festus Eghe Agbonzikilo ◽  
Ieuan Owen ◽  
Suresh Kumar Sadasivuni ◽  
Ronald A. Bickerton

This paper presents the results of a detailed investigation of the fuel-air mixing processes that take place within the radial swirler slot of a dry low emission combustion system. The aerodynamics of the flow within the slot is complex and this, together with the placement of the fuel holes with cross injection, controls the mixing of the fuel and air. Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) with the Shear Stress Transport (k-ω) turbulence model was used for flow and mixing predictions within the radial swirler slot and for conducting a CFD-based Design of Experiments (DOE) optimisation study, in which different parameters related to the fuel injection holes were varied. The optimisation study was comprised of 25 orthogonal design configurations in a Taguchi L25 orthogonal array. The test domain for the CFD, and its experimental validation, was a large-scale representation of a swirler slot from a Siemens proprietary DLE combustion system. The DOE study showed that the number of fuel holes, injection hole diameter and inter-hole distance are the most influential parameters for determining optimal fuel mixing. Consequently, the optimised mixing configuration obtained from the above study was experimentally tested on an atmospheric test facility. The mixing patterns from experiments at various axial locations across the slot are in good agreement with the mixing predictions from the optimal CFD model. The optimised fuel injection design improved mixing compared with the original design by about 60%.


Author(s):  
Festus Eghe Agbonzikilo ◽  
Ieuan Owen ◽  
Jill Stewart ◽  
Suresh Kumar Sadasivuni ◽  
Mike Riley ◽  
...  

This paper presents the results of an investigation in which the fuel/air mixing process in a single slot within the radial swirler of a dry low emission (DLE) combustion system is explored using air/air mixing. Experimental studies have been carried out on an atmospheric test facility in which the test domain is a large-scale representation of a swirler slot from a Siemens proprietary DLE combustion system. Hot air with a temperature of 300 °C is supplied to the slot, while the injected fuel gas is simulated using air jets with temperatures of about 25 °C. Temperature has been used as a scalar to measure the mixing of the jets with the cross-flow. The mixture temperatures were measured using thermocouples while Pitot probes were used to obtain local velocity measurements. The experimental data have been used to validate a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) mixing model. Numerical simulations were carried out using CFD software ansys-cfx. Due to the complex three-dimensional flow structure inside the swirler slot, different Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes (RANS) turbulence models were tested. The shear stress transport (SST) turbulence model was observed to give best agreement with the experimental data. The momentum flux ratio between the main air flow and the injected fuel jet, and the aerodynamics inside the slot were both identified by this study as major factors in determining the mixing characteristics. It has been shown that mixing in the swirler can be significantly improved by exploiting the aerodynamic characteristics of the flow inside the slot. The validated CFD model provides a tool which will be used in future studies to explore fuel/air mixing at engine conditions.


Author(s):  
Festus Eghe Agbonzikilo ◽  
Jill Stewart ◽  
Suresh Kumar Sadasivuni ◽  
Ieuan Owen ◽  
Mike Riley ◽  
...  

This paper presents the results of an investigation in which the fuel/air mixing process in a single slot within the radial swirler of a dry low emission (DLE) combustion system is explored using air/air mixing. Experimental studies have been carried out on an atmospheric test facility in which the test domain is a large-scale representation of a swirler slot from a Siemens DLE SGT-400 combustion system. Hot air with a temperature of 300°C is supplied to the slot, while the injected fuel gas is represented using air jets with temperatures of about 25°C. Temperature has been used as a scalar to measure the mixing of the jets with the cross-flow. The mixture temperatures were measured using thermocouples while Pitot probes were used to obtain local velocity measurements. The experimental data have been used to validate a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) mixing model. Numerical simulations were carried out using CFD software ANSYS-CFX. Due to the complex three-dimensional flow structure inside the swirler slot, different RANS turbulence models were tested. The shear stress transport (SST) turbulence model was observed to give best agreement with the experimental data. The momentum flux ratio between the main air flow and the injected fuel jet, and the aerodynamics inside the slot, were both identified by this study as major factors in determining the mixing characteristics. It has been shown that mixing in the swirler can be significantly improved by exploiting the aerodynamic characteristics of the flow inside the slot. The validated CFD model provides a tool which will be used in future studies to explore fuel/air mixing at engine conditions.


Author(s):  
Yonas Niguse ◽  
Ajay Agrawal

The objective of this study is to develop a theoretical basis for scalability considerations and design of a large-scale combustor utilizing flow blurring (FB) atomization. FB atomization is a recently discovered twin-fluid atomization concept, reported to produce fine spray of liquids with wide range of viscosities. Previously, we have developed and investigated a small-scale swirl-stabilized combustor of 7-kWth capacity. Spray measurements have shown that the FB injector's atomization capability is superior when compared to other techniques, such as air blast atomization. However, despite these favorable results, scalability of the FB injector and associated combustor design has never been explored for large capacity; for example, for gas turbine applications. In this study, a number of dimensionless scaling parameters that affect the processes of atomization, fuel–air mixing, and combustion are analyzed, and scaling criteria for the different components of the combustion system are selected. Constant velocity criterion is used to scale key geometric components of the system. Scaling of the nonlinear dimensions and complex geometries, such as swirler vanes and internal parts of the injector is undertaken through phenomenological analysis of the flow processes associated with the scaled component. A scaled-up 60-kWth capacity combustor with FB injector is developed and investigated for combustion performance using diesel and vegetable oil (VO) (soybean oil) as fuels. Results show that the scaled-up injector's performance is comparable to the smaller scale system in terms of flame quality, emission levels, and static flame stability. Visual flame images at different atomizing air-to-liquid ratio by mass (ALR) show mainly blue flames, especially for ALR > 2.8. Emission measurements show a general trend of lower CO and NOx levels at higher ALRs, replicating the performance of the small-scale combustion system. Flame liftoff height at different ALRs is similar for both scales. The scaled-up combustor with FB injector preformed robustly with uncompromised stability for the range of firing rates (FRs) above 50% of the design capacity. Experimental results corroborate with the scaling methodology developed in this research.


Author(s):  
Yonas G. Niguse ◽  
Ajay K. Agrawal

The objective of this study is to develop a theoretical basis for scalability considerations and design of a large scale combustor utilizing flow blurring (FB) atomization. FB atomization is a recently discovered twin-fluid atomization concept, reported to produce fine spray of liquids with wide range of viscosities. Previously, we have developed and investigated a small scale swirl-stabilized combustor of 7-kWth capacity. Spray measurements have shown that the FB injector’s atomization capability is superior when compared to other techniques, such as air blast atomization. However, despite these favorable results, scalability of the FB injector and associated combustor design has never been explored for large capacity, for example, for gas turbine applications. In this study, a number of dimensionless scaling parameters that affect the processes of atomization, fuel-air mixing, and combustion are analyzed, and scaling criteria for the different components of the combustion system are selected. Constant velocity criterion is used to scale key geometric components of the system. Scaling of the nonlinear dimensions and complex geometries, such as swirler vanes and internal parts of the injector is undertaken through phenomenological analysis of the flow processes associated with the scaled component. A scaled up 60-kWth capacity combustor with FB injector is developed and investigated for combustion performance using diesel and vegetable oil (soybean oil) as fuels. Results show that the scaled-up injector’s performance is comparable to the smaller scale system in terms of flame quality, emission levels, and static flame stability. Visual flame images at different air to liquid ratio by mass (ALR) show mainly blue flames, especially for ALR > 2.8. Emission measurements show a general trend of lower CO and NOx levels at higher ALRs, replicating the performance of the small scale combustion system. Flame liftoff height at different ALRs is similar for both scales. The scaled-up combustor with FB injector preformed robustly with uncompromised stability for the range of firing rates above 50% of the design capacity. Experimental results corroborate with the scaling methodology developed in this research.


Author(s):  
Frank Reiss ◽  
Sven-Hendrik Wiers ◽  
Ulrich Orth ◽  
Emil Aschenbruck ◽  
Martin Lauer ◽  
...  

This paper describes the development and test results of the low emission combustion system for the new industrial gas turbines in the 6–7 MW class from MAN Diesel & Turbo. The design of a robust combustion system and the achievement of very low emission targets were the most important design goals of the combustor development. During the design phase, the analysis of the combustor (i.e. burner design, air distribution, liner cooling design) was supported with different CFD tools. This advanced Dry Low Emission can combustion system (ACC) consists of 6 cans mounted externally on the gas turbine. The behavior and performance of a single can sector was tested over a wide load range and with different boundary conditions; first on an atmospheric test rig and later on a high pressure test rig with extensive instrumentation to ensure an efficient test campaign and accurate data. The atmospheric tests showed a very good performance for all combustor parts and promising results. The high pressure tests demonstrated very stable behavior at all operation modes and very low emissions to satisfy stringent environmental requirements. The whole operation concept of the combustion system was tested first on the single-can high pressure test bed and later on twin and single shaft gas turbines at MAN’s gas turbine test facility. During the engine tests, the can combustors demonstrated the expected combustion performance under real operation conditions. All emissions and performance targets were fully achieved. On the single shaft engine, the combustors were running with single digit ppm NOx levels between 50% and 100% load. The validation phase and further optimization of the gas turbines and the engine components are ongoing. The highlights of the development process and results of the combustor and engine tests will be presented and discussed within this paper.


Author(s):  
Boris F. Kock ◽  
Bernd Prade ◽  
Benjamin Witzel ◽  
Holger Streb ◽  
Mike H. Koenig

The first Siemens AG SGT5-4000F engine with hybrid burner ring combustor (HBR) was introduced in 1996. Since then, frequent evolutionary design improvements of the combustion system were introduced to fulfill the continuously changing market requirements. The improvements particularly focused on increased thermodynamic performance, reduced emissions, and increasing operational flexibility in terms of load gradients, fuel flexibility, and turndown capability. According to the Siemens product development process, every design evolution had to pass several validation steps to ensure high reliability and best performance. The single steps included cold flow and mixing tests at atmospheric pressure, high-pressure combustion tests in full-scale sector combustion test rigs, and full engine tests at the Berlin test facility (BTF). After successful validation, the design improvements were gradually released for commercial operation. In a first step, cooling air reduction features have been implemented in 2005, followed by the introduction of a premixed pilot as second step in 2006. Both together resulted in a significant reduction of the NOx emissions of the system. In a third step, an aerodynamic burner modification was introduced in 2007, which improved the thermo-acoustic stability of the system towards higher turbine inlet temperatures and adapted to fuel preheating to allow for increased cycle efficiency. All three features together have been released as package in 2010 and to date accumulated more than 50,000 operating hours (fleet leader 24,000). This paper reports upon the steps towards this latest design status of the SGT5-4000F and presents results from typical focus areas of lean premixed combustion systems in gas turbines including aero-dynamical optimization, fuel/air mixing improvements and cooling air management in the combustor.


Author(s):  
Daniel Guyot ◽  
Gabrielle Tea ◽  
Christoph Appel

Reducing gas turbine emissions and increasing their operational flexibility are key targets in today’s gas turbine market. In order to further reduce emissions and increase the operational flexibility of its GT24 (60Hz) and GT26 (50Hz), Alstom has introduced an improved SEV burner and fuel lance into its GT24 upgrade 2011 and GT26 upgrade 2011 sequential reheat combustion system. Sequential combustion is a key differentiator of Alstom GT24 engines in the F-class gas turbine market. The inlet temperature for the GT24 SEV combustor is around 1000 degC and reaction of the fuel/oxidant mixture is initiated through auto-ignition. The recent development of the Alstom sequential combustion system is a perfect example of evolutionary design optimizations and technology transfer between Alstom GT24 and GT26 engines. Better overall performance is achieved through improved SEV burner aerodynamics and fuel injection, while keeping the main features of the sequential burner technology. The improved SEV burner/lance concept has been optimized towards rapid fuel/oxidant mixing for low emissions, improved fuel flexibility with regards to highly reactive fuels (higher C2+ and hydrogen content), and to sustain a wide operation window. In addition, the burner front panel features an improved cooling concept based on near-wall cooling as well as integrated acoustics damping devices designed to reduce combustion pulsations thus extending the SEV combustor’s operation window even further. After having been validated extensively in the Alstom high pressure sector rig test facility, the improved GT24 SEV burner has been retrofitted into a commercial GT24 field engine for full engine validation during long-term operation. This paper presents the obtained high pressure sector rig and engine validation results for the GT24 (2011) SEV burner/lance hardware with a focus on reduced NOX and CO emissions and improved operational behavior of the SEV combustor. The high pressure tests demonstrated robust SEV burner/lance operation with up to 50% lower NOX formation and a more than 70K higher SEV burner inlet temperature compared to the GT24 (2006) hardware. For the GT24 engine with retrofitted upgrade 2011 SEV burner/lance all validation targets were achieved including an extremely robust operation behavior, up to 40% lower GT NOX emissions, significantly lower CO emissions at partload and baseload, a very broad operation window (up to 100K width in SEV combustor inlet temperature) and all measured SEV burner/lance temperatures in the expected range. Sector rig and engine validation results have confirmed the expected SEV burner fuel flexibility (up to 18%-vol. C2+ and up to 5%-vol. hydrogen as standard).


Author(s):  
Daniel Guyot ◽  
Gabrielle Tea ◽  
Christoph Appel

Reducing gas turbine emissions and increasing their operational flexibility are key targets in today's gas turbine market. In order to further reduce emissions and increase the operational flexibility of its GT24 (60 Hz) and GT26 (50 Hz), Alstom has introduced an improved sequential environmental (SEV) burner and fuel lance into its GT24 and GT26 upgrades 2011 sequential reheat combustion system. Sequential combustion is a key differentiator of Alstom GT24/GT26 engines in the F-class gas turbine market. The inlet temperature for the SEV combustor is around 1000 °C and reaction of the fuel/oxidant mixture is initiated through auto-ignition. The recent development of the Alstom sequential combustion system is a perfect example of evolutionary design optimizations and technology transfer between Alstom GT24 and GT26 engines. Better overall performance is achieved through improved SEV burner aerodynamics and fuel injection, while keeping the main features of the sequential burner technology. The improved SEV burner/lance concept has been optimized toward rapid fuel/oxidant mixing for low emissions, improved fuel flexibility with regard to highly reactive fuels (higher C2+ and hydrogen content), and to sustain a wide operation window. The burner front panel features an improved cooling concept based on near-wall cooling as well as integrated acoustics damping devices designed to reduce combustion pulsations, thus extending the SEV combustor's operation window even further. After having been validated extensively in Alstom's high pressure (HP) sector rig test facility, the improved GT24 SEV burner has been retrofitted into a commercial GT24 field engine for full engine validation during long-term operation. This paper presents the obtained HP sector rig and engine validation results for the GT24 (2011) SEV burner/lance hardware with a focus on reduced NOx and CO emissions and improved operational behavior of the SEV combustor. The HP tests demonstrated robust SEV burner/lance operation with up to 50% lower NOx formation and a more than 70 K higher SEV burner inlet temperature compared to the GT24 (2006) hardware. For the GT24 engine with retrofitted upgrade 2011 SEV burner/lance, all validation targets were achieved including an extremely robust operation behavior, up to 40% lower GT NOx emissions, significantly lower CO emissions at partload and baseload, a very broad operation window (up to 100 K width in SEV combustor inlet temperature), and all measured SEV burner/lance temperatures in the expected range. Sector rig and engine validation results have confirmed the expected SEV burner fuel flexibility (up to 18 vol. % C2+ and up to 5 vol. % hydrogen as standard).


Author(s):  
Holger Huitenga ◽  
Eric R. Norster

The THM series of industrial gas turbines covers a power range of 6 to 12.5 MW and has been improved and uprated over many years. The majority of turbines installed are still in commercial operation and they are mainly used for compressor drives but also find generator applications. In recent years the constraints of emission legislations for new and existing gas turbines has made a development programme for a dry low emission (DLE) combustion system essential. The combustion system apart from meeting latest emission targets of 75 mg/mN3 NOx and 100 mg/mN3 CO must be suitable for both, new and retrofit engine options and therefore compact for standard enclosure installation. In addition the design should be simple and robust with the same accessibility as the existing standard combustion system. The paper describes the design and development steps to provide a prototype lean premixed DLE combustion system. The basic approach for a simple lean premixed design together with aero-thermodynamic sizing for pressure loss, flow proportions, stability and cooling is described. The initial efforts were directed to a system for the 11 MW THM 1304-11AP machine, with combustor atmospheric testing to verify design parameters and operating limits. The development was continued by subsequent high pressure testing of the prototype, starting with suitable units in the MAN engine test facility, omitting any high pressure rig tests. Field tests were carried out on a compressor drive application on a gas pumping station to prove long term durability. Adaptations of the design are now engine-tested for other THM models, even recuperated ones. Also, the combustor technology and methods developed here provide the basis for the combustors on the new MAN MGT 6100 and 6200 engines [1].


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document