An Experimental Study of Continuous and Discrete Visualization Paradigms for Interactive Trade Space Exploration

Author(s):  
Brian J. German ◽  
Karen M. Feigh ◽  
Matthew J. Daskilewicz

Software tools that enable interactive data visualization are now commonly available for engineering design. These tools allow engineers to inspect, filter, and select promising alternatives from large multivariate design spaces based upon an examination of the tradeoffs between multiple objectives. There are two general approaches for visually representing data: (1) discretely, by plotting a sample of designs as distinct points; and (2) continuously, by plotting the functional relationships between design variables and design metrics as curves or surfaces. In this paper, we examine these two approaches through a human subjects experiment. Participants were asked to complete two design tasks with an interactive visualization tool: one by using a sample of discrete designs and one by using a continuous representation of the design space. Metrics describing the optimality of the design outcomes, the usage of different graphics, and the task workload were quantified by mouse tracking, user process descriptions, and analysis of the selected designs. The results indicate that users had more difficultly in selecting multiobjective optimal designs with common continuous graphics than with discrete graphics. The findings suggest that innovative features and additional usability studies are required in order for continuous trade space visualization tools to achieve their full potential.

Author(s):  
Hyunseung Bang ◽  
Daniel Selva

One of the major challenges faced by the decision maker in the design of complex engineering systems is information overload. When the size and dimensionality of the data exceeds a certain level, a designer may become overwhelmed and no longer be able to perceive and analyze the underlying dynamics of the design problem at hand, which can result in premature or poor design selection. There exist various knowledge discovery and visual analytic tools designed to relieve the information overload, such as BrickViz, Cloud Visualization, ATSV, and LIVE, to name a few. However, most of them do not explicitly support the discovery of key knowledge about the mapping between the design space and the objective space, such as the set of high-level design features that drive most of the trade-offs between objectives. In this paper, we introduce a new interactive method, called iFEED, that supports the designer in the process of high-level knowledge discovery in a large, multiobjective design space. The primary goal of the method is to iteratively mine the design space dataset for driving features, i.e., combinations of design variables that appear to consistently drive designs towards specific target regions in the design space set by the user. This is implemented using a data mining algorithm that mines interesting patterns in the form of association rules. The extracted patterns are then used to build a surrogate classification model based on a decision tree that predicts whether a design is likely to be located in the target region of the tradespace or not. Higher level features will generate more compact classification trees while improving classification accuracy. If the mined features are not satisfactory, the user can go back to the first step and extract higher level features. Such iterative process helps the user to gain insights and build a mental model of how design variables are mapped into objective values. A controlled experiment with human subjects is designed to test the effectiveness of the proposed method. A preliminary result from the pilot experiment is presented.


2006 ◽  
Author(s):  
◽  
Ryan Jason Hamilton

Fibre Reinforced Plastics (FRPs) have been used in many practical structural applications due to their excellent strength and weight characteristics as well as the ability for their properties to be tailored to the requirements of a given application. Thus, designing with FRPs can be extremely challenging, particularly when the number of design variables contained in the design space is large. For example, to determine the ply orientations and the material properties optimally is typically difficult without a considered approach. Optimization of composite structures with respect to the ply angles is necessary to realize the full potential of fibre-reinforced materials. Evaluating the fitness of each candidate in the design space, and selecting the most efficient can be very time consuming and costly. Structures composed of composite materials often contain components which may be modelled as rectangular plates or cylindrical shells, for example. Modelling of components such as plates can be useful as it is a means of simplifying elements of structures, and this can save time and thus cost. Variations in manufacturing processes and user environment may affect the quality and performance of a product. It is usually beneficial to account for such variances or tolerances in the design process, and in fact, sometimes it may be crucial, particularly when the effect is of consequence. The work conducted within this project focused on methodologies for optimally designing fibre-reinforced laminated composite structures with the effects of manufacturing tolerances included. For this study it is assumed that the probability of any tolerance value occurring within the tolerance band, compared with any other, is equal, and thus the techniques are aimed at designing for the worst-case scenario. This thesis thus discusses four new procedures for the optimization of composite structures with the effects of manufacturing uncertainties included.


2009 ◽  
Vol 43 (2) ◽  
pp. 48-60 ◽  
Author(s):  
M. Martz ◽  
W. L. Neu

AbstractThe design of complex systems involves a number of choices, the implications of which are interrelated. If these choices are made sequentially, each choice may limit the options available in subsequent choices. Early choices may unknowingly limit the effectiveness of a final design in this way. Only a formal process that considers all possible choices (and combinations of choices) can insure that the best option has been selected. Complex design problems may easily present a number of choices to evaluate that is prohibitive. Modern optimization algorithms attempt to navigate a multidimensional design space in search of an optimal combination of design variables. A design optimization process for an autonomous underwater vehicle is developed using a multiple objective genetic optimization algorithm that searches the design space, evaluating designs based on three measures of performance: cost, effectiveness, and risk. A synthesis model evaluates the characteristics of a design having any chosen combination of design variable values. The effectiveness determined by the synthesis model is based on nine attributes identified in the U.S. Navy’s Unmanned Undersea Vehicle Master Plan and four performance-based attributes calculated by the synthesis model. The analytical hierarchy process is used to synthesize these attributes into a single measure of effectiveness. The genetic algorithm generates a set of Pareto optimal, feasible designs from which a decision maker(s) can choose designs for further analysis.


2019 ◽  
Vol 36 (3) ◽  
pp. 245-256
Author(s):  
Yoonki Kim ◽  
Sanga Lee ◽  
Kwanjung Yee ◽  
Young-Seok Kang

Abstract The purpose of this study is to optimize the 1st stage of the transonic high pressure turbine (HPT) for enhancement of aerodynamic performance. Isentropic total-to-total efficiency is designated as the objective function. Since the isentropic efficiency can be improved through modifying the geometry of vane and rotor blade, lean angle and sweep angle are chosen as design variables, which can effectively alter the blade geometry. The sensitivities of each design variable are investigated by applying lean and sweep angles to the base nozzle and rotor, respectively. The design space is also determined based on the results of the parametric study. For the design of experiment (DoE), Optimal Latin Hypercube sampling is adopted, so that 25 evenly distributed samples are selected on the design space. Sequentially, based on the values from the CFD calculation, Kriging surrogate model is constructed and refined using Expected Improvement (EI). With the converged surrogate model, optimum solution is sought by using the Genetic Algorithm. As a result, the efficiency of optimum turbine 1st stage is increased by 1.07 % point compared to that of the base turbine 1st stage. Also, the blade loading, pressure distribution, static entropy, shock structure, and secondary flow are thoroughly discussed.


2017 ◽  
Vol 139 (11) ◽  
Author(s):  
Wei Chen ◽  
Mark Fuge

To solve a design problem, sometimes it is necessary to identify the feasible design space. For design spaces with implicit constraints, sampling methods are usually used. These methods typically bound the design space; that is, limit the range of design variables. But bounds that are too small will fail to cover all possible designs, while bounds that are too large will waste sampling budget. This paper tries to solve the problem of efficiently discovering (possibly disconnected) feasible domains in an unbounded design space. We propose a data-driven adaptive sampling technique—ε-margin sampling, which learns the domain boundary of feasible designs and also expands our knowledge on the design space as available budget increases. This technique is data-efficient, in that it makes principled probabilistic trade-offs between refining existing domain boundaries versus expanding the design space. We demonstrate that this method can better identify feasible domains on standard test functions compared to both random and active sampling (via uncertainty sampling). However, a fundamental problem when applying adaptive sampling to real world designs is that designs often have high dimensionality and thus require (in the worst case) exponentially more samples per dimension. We show how coupling design manifolds with ε-margin sampling allows us to actively expand high-dimensional design spaces without incurring this exponential penalty. We demonstrate this on real-world examples of glassware and bottle design, where our method discovers designs that have different appearance and functionality from its initial design set.


Author(s):  
Salman Ahmed ◽  
Mihir Sunil Gawand ◽  
Lukman Irshad ◽  
H. Onan Demirel

Computational human factors tools are often not fully-integrated during the early phases of product design. Often, conventional ergonomic practices require physical prototypes and human subjects which are costly in terms of finances and time. Ergonomics evaluations executed on physical prototypes has the limitations of increasing the overall rework as more iterations are required to incorporate design changes related to human factors that are found later in the design stage, which affects the overall cost of product development. This paper proposes a design methodology based on Digital Human Modeling (DHM) approach to inform designers about the ergonomics adequacies of products during early stages of design process. This proactive ergonomics approach has the potential to allow designers to identify significant design variables that affect the human performance before full-scale prototypes are built. The design method utilizes a surrogate model that represents human product interaction. Optimizing the surrogate model provides design concepts to optimize human performance. The efficacy of the proposed design method is demonstrated by a cockpit design study.


2014 ◽  
Vol 2014 ◽  
pp. 1-8 ◽  
Author(s):  
Rameez Badhurshah ◽  
Abdus Samad

Surrogates are cheaper to evaluate and assist in designing systems with lesser time. On the other hand, the surrogates are problem dependent and they need evaluation for each problem to find a suitable surrogate. The Kriging variants such as ordinary, universal, and blind along with commonly used response surface approximation (RSA) model were used in the present problem, to optimize the performance of an air impulse turbine used for ocean wave energy harvesting by CFD analysis. A three-level full factorial design was employed to find sample points in the design space for two design variables. A Reynolds-averaged Navier Stokes solver was used to evaluate the objective function responses, and these responses along with the design variables were used to construct the Kriging variants and RSA functions. A hybrid genetic algorithm was used to find the optimal point in the design space. It was found that the best optimal design was produced by the universal Kriging while the blind Kriging produced the worst. The present approach is suggested for renewable energy application.


2020 ◽  
pp. 1-12
Author(s):  
Qiang Zheng ◽  
Hai-Chao Chang ◽  
Zu-Yuan Liu ◽  
Bai-Wei Feng

Hull optimization design based on computational fluid dynamics (CFD) is a highly computationally intensive complex engineering problem. Because of reasons such as many variables, spatially complex design performance, and huge computational workload, hull optimization efficiency is low. To improve the efficiency of hull optimization, a dynamic space reduction method based on a partial correlation analysis is proposed in this study. The proposed method dynamically uses hull-form optimization data to analyze and reduce the range of values for relevant design variables and, thus, considerably improves the optimization efficiency. This method is used to optimize the wave-making resistance of an S60 hull, and its feasibility is verified through comparison. 1. Introduction In recent years, to promote the rapid development of green ships, hull optimization methods based on computational fluid dynamics (CFD) have been widely used by many researchers, such as Tahara et al. (2011), Peri and Diez (2013), Kim and Yang (2010), Yang and Huang (2016), Chang et al. (2012), and Feng et al. (2009). However, hull optimization design is a typically complex engineering problem. It requires many numerical simulation calculations, and the design performance space is complex, which has resulted in low optimization efficiency and difficulty in obtaining a global optimal solution. Commonly used solutions include 1) efficient optimization algorithms, 2) approximate model techniques, and 3) high-performance cluster computers. However, these methods still cannot satisfy the engineering application requirements in terms of efficiency and quality of the solution. To solve the problem of low optimization efficiency and difficulty in obtaining an optimal solution in engineering optimization problems, many scholars have conducted research on design space reduction technology. Reungsinkonkarn and Apirukvorapinit (2014) applied the search space reduction (SSR) algorithm to the particle swarm optimization (PSO) algorithm, eliminating areas in which optimal solutions may not be found through SSR to improve the optimization efficiency of the algorithm. Chen et al. (2015) and Diez et al. (2014, 2015) used the Karhunen–Loeve expansion to evaluate the hull, eliminating the less influential factors to achieve space reduction modeling with fewer design variables. Further extensions to nonlinear dimensionality reduction methods can be found in D'Agostino et al. (2017) and Serani et al. (2019). Jeong et al. (2005) applied space reduction techniques to the aerodynamic shape optimization of the vane wheel, using the rough set theory and decision trees to extract aerofoil design rules to improve each target. Gao et al. (2009) and Wang et al. (2014) solved the problem of low optimization efficiency in the aerodynamic shape optimization design of an aircraft, by using analysis results of partial correlation, which reduced the range of values of relevant design variables to reconstruct the optimized design space. Li et al. (2013) divided the design space into several smaller cluster spaces using the clustering method, which is a global optimization method based on an approximation model, thus achieving design space reduction. Chu (2010) combined the rough set theory and the clustering method for application to the concept design stage of bulk carriers, thus realizing the exploration and reduction of design space. Feng et al. (2015) applied the rough set theory and the sequential space reduction method to the resistance optimization of typical ship hulls to achieve the reduction of design space. Wu et al. (2016) used partial correlation analysis to reduce the design space of variables of a KCS container ship to improve optimization efficiency. Most of the above space reduction methods need to sample and calculate the original design space in the early stage of optimization and then obtain the reduced design space through data mining. This process increases the computational cost of sampling, making it difficult to control optimization efficiency.


Author(s):  
David Wolf ◽  
Jennifer Hyland ◽  
Timothy W. Simpson ◽  
Xiaolong (Luke) Zhang

Thanks to recent advances in computing power and speed, engineers can now generate a wealth of data on demand to support design decision-making. These advances have enabled new approaches to search multidimensional trade spaces through interactive data visualization and exploration. In this paper, we investigate the effectiveness and efficiency of interactive trade space exploration strategies by conducting human subject experiments with novice and expert users. A single objective, constrained design optimization problem involving the sizing of an engine combustion chamber is used for this study. Effectiveness is measured by comparing the best feasible design obtained by each user, and efficiency is assessed based on the percentage of feasible designs generated by each user. Results indicate that novices who watch a 5-min training video before the experiment obtain results that are not significantly different from those obtained by expert users, and both groups are statistically better than the novices without the training video in terms of effectiveness and efficiency. Frequency and ordering of the visualization and exploration tools are also compared to understand the differences in each group’s search strategy. The implications of the results are discussed along with future work.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document