A Re-Examination of Propane Tank Tub Rockets Including Field Trial Results

1997 ◽  
Vol 119 (3) ◽  
pp. 356-364 ◽  
Author(s):  
T. Miller ◽  
A. M. Birk

When a tank containing a pressure-liquefied gas fails, one mode of failure involves the tank being propelled large distances by the released two-phase material. This mode of failure is called a tub rocket and it can pose a severe hazard to the public because of its unpredictability. Field tests were recently conducted to study the effect of explosive devices on propane tanks. The tests included tanks of various sizes up to 2000 L (500 gal).In most cases, the tests resulted in punctured tanks with transient two-phase jet releases. In some cases, the jet releases were sufficient to propel the tanks over considerable distances. In a small number of tests involving 470-L tanks, the explosive device resulted in the clean removal of a tank end, and this resulted in near-ideal launches of tub rockets. In one case, the rocket was launched vertically, and in another, the rocket was launched near 45 deg elevation angle giving a tub range of 370 m. In other cases, the explosive devices resulted in punctures, and in some of these, the resulting two-phase jet propelled the tanks over considerable distance. These examples gave a good opportunity to re-examine tub rocket models for tanks containing liquefied gases. This paper describes a theoretical model involving two-phase critical flow propulsion of cylindrical tanks. Three different critical flow models are compared, including the homogeneous equilibrium model (HEM), the homogeneous frozen model (HFM), and the Henry-Fauske model (HFK). Range predictions are compared with existing data and a model previously developed. Model predictions are calibrated to the field trial results described in the foregoing and then used to predict realistic ranges for various sizes of storage and transport tanks.

Author(s):  
Philippe Lafon ◽  
Mohamed Essadki ◽  
Yann Bartosiewicz ◽  
Jean-Marie Seynhaeve

The discharge of a subcooled liquid or a liquid-vapor mixture at high temperature and pressure can occur in many industrial situations. This paper is focused on the analysis of critical flow models that are already available in the fast transient dynamics software EUROPLEXUS, or that are being implemented as new break boundary conditions. The results of the Moody, Fauske, Flinta, Henry-Fauske and DEM models are presented and compared with the Super Moby Dick experimental results. The best results are obtained for the DEM. Then preliminary results concerning the implementation of the DEM model as a break boundary condition in EUROPLEXUS are given.


1990 ◽  
Vol 112 (3) ◽  
pp. 187-191 ◽  
Author(s):  
R. V. A. Oliemans ◽  
B. F. M. Pots ◽  
H. L. Wu

The predictive power of a two-phase flow design method, consisting of one-dimensional flow models depending both on flow regime and pipe inclination, has been investigated by comparing predicted pressure losses and liquid hold-ups with pipeline data collected under actual conditions. For this purpose, Shell’s database of controlled field tests in large-size gas pipelines was extended with data obtained in an 8-in. high-pressure two-phase flow test facility with gas and condensate as flowing media. It was concluded that the predictive power was reasonable for wide ranges of flow conditions, but that liquid entrainment is to be incorporated in models to remove conservatism from liquid hold-up predictions.


2020 ◽  
Vol 6 (4) ◽  
Author(s):  
Milan Tesinsky

Abstract The Moody and Henry–Fauske critical flow models implemented in Advanced Process Simulation Software (apros) have been validated against Marviken critical flow experiments and compared with other available simulations of the same experiments. Both models in combination with discharge coefficient 0.75 (suggested for best estimate calculations) produce results close to the experimental data for two-phase flows, while one-phase flow of subcooled water is underpredicted. Using discharge coefficient 1.0 for subcooled water leads to a good match with the experimental results, while two-phase flows become overpredicted.


1968 ◽  
Vol 10 (4) ◽  
pp. 337-345 ◽  
Author(s):  
D. J Ryley ◽  
G. J. Parker

As part of an investigation to study the removal of water from the trailing edge of a low pressure steam turbine fixed blade by suction slots, experiments were made on a perspex test section in which a 1-in wide section of the suction slot was simulated. The flow characteristics are considered of the passage in the choked condition and a comparison is made with some two-phase critical flow theories. The theories are briefly presented and discussed, and the relevant formulae given. It is found that the homogeneous-equilibrium model grossly underestimates the discharge rates whilst all of the other flow models overestimate by at least 30 per cent.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document