Flow Nonuniformities and Turbulent “Hot Spots” Due to Wake-Blade and Wake-Wake Interactions in a Multi-Stage Turbomachine

2002 ◽  
Vol 124 (4) ◽  
pp. 553-563 ◽  
Author(s):  
Yi-Chih Chow ◽  
Oguz Uzol ◽  
Joseph Katz

This experimental study provides striking examples of the complex flow and turbulence structure resulting from blade-wake and wake-wake interactions in a multi-stage turbomachine. Particle image velocimetry (PIV) measurements are performed within the entire 2nd stage of a two-stage turbomachine. The experiments are performed in a facility that allows unobstructed view of the entire flow field, facilitated using transparent rotor and stator and a fluid that has the same optical index of refraction as the blades. This paper contains data on the phase-averaged flow structure including velocity, vorticity and strain-rate, as well as the turbulent kinetic energy and shear stress, at mid span, for several orientation of the rotor relative to the stator. Two different test setups with different blade geometries are used in order to highlight and elucidate complex phenomena involved, as well as to demonstrate that some of the interactions are characteristic to turbomachines and can be found in a variety of geometries. The first part of the paper deals with the interaction of a 2nd-stage rotor with the wakes of both the rotor and the stator of the 1st stage. Even before interacting with the blade, localized regions with concentrated mean vorticity and elevated turbulence levels form at the intersection of the rotor and stator wakes of the 1st stage. These phenomena persist even after being ingested by the rotor blade of the 2nd stage. As the wake segment of the 1st-stage rotor blade arrives to the 2nd stage, the rotor blades become submerged in its elevated turbulence levels, and separate the region with negative vorticity that travels along the pressure side of the blade, from the region with positive vorticity that remains on the suction side. The 1st-stage stator wake is chopped-off by the blades. Due to difference in mean lateral velocity, the stator wake segment on the pressure side is advected faster than the segment on the suction side (in the absolute frame of reference), creating discontinuities in the stator wake trajectory. The nonuniformities in phase-averaged velocity distributions generated by the wakes of the 1st stage persist while passing through the 2nd-stage rotor. The combined effects of the 1st-stage blade rows cause 10–12 deg variations of flow angle along the pressure side of the blade. Thus, in spite of the large gap between the 1st and 2nd rotors (compared to typical rotor-stator spacings in axial compressors), 6.5 rotor axial chords, the wake-blade interactions are substantial. The second part focuses on the flow structure at the intersection of the wakes generated by a rotor and a stator located upstream of it. In both test setups the rotor wake is sheared by the nonuniformities in the axial velocity distributions, which are a direct result of the “discontinuities” in the trajectories of the stator wake. This shearing creates a kink in the trajectory of the rotor wake, a quadruple structure in the distribution of strain, regions with concentrated vorticity, high turbulence levels and high shear stresses, the latter with a complex structure that resembles the mean strain. Although the “hot spots” diffuse as they are advected downstream, they still have elevated turbulence levels compared to the local levels around them. In fact, every region of wake intersection has an elevated turbulence level.

Author(s):  
Yi-Chih Chow ◽  
Oguz Uzol ◽  
Joseph Katz

This experimental study provides striking examples of the complex flow and turbulence structure resulting from blade-wake and wake-wake interactions in a multi-stage turbomachine. Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) measurements are performed within the entire 2nd stage of a two-stage turbomachine. The experiments are performed in a facility that allows unobstructed view of the entire flow field, facilitated using transparent rotor and stator and a fluid that has the same optical index of refraction as the blades. This paper contains data on the phase-averaged flow structure including velocity, vorticity and strain-rate, as well as the turbulent kinetic energy and shear stress, at mid span, for several orientation of the rotor relative to the stator. Two different test setups with different blade geometries are used in order to highlight and elucidate complex phenomena involved, as well as to demonstrate that some of the interactions are characteristic to turbomachines and can be found in a variety of geometries. The first part of the paper deals with the interaction of a 2nd stage rotor with the wakes of both the rotor and the stator of the 1st stage. Even before interacting with the blade, localized regions with concentrated mean vorticity and elevated turbulence levels form at the intersection of the rotor and stator wakes of the 1st stage. These phenomena persist even after being ingested by the rotor blade of the 2nd stage. As the wake segment of the 1st stage rotor blade arrives to the 2nd stage, the rotor blades become submerged in its elevated turbulence levels, and separate the region with positive vorticity that travels along the pressure side of the blade, from the region with negative vorticity that remains on the suction side. The 1st stage stator wake is chopped-off by the blades. Due to difference in mean tangential velocity, the stator wake segment on the pressure side is advected faster than the segment on the suction side (in the absolute frame of reference), creating discontinuities in the stator wake trajectory. The non-uniformities in phase-averaged velocity distributions generated by the wakes of the 1st stage persist while passing through the 2nd stage rotor. The combined effects of the 1st stage blade rows cause 10°–12° variations of flow angle along the pressure side of the blade. Thus, in spite of the large gap between the 1st and 2nd rotors (compared to typical rotor-stator spacings in axial compressors), 6.5 rotor axial chords, the wake-blade interactions are substantial. The second part focuses on the flow structure at the intersection of the wakes generated by a rotor and a stator located upstream of it. In both test setups the rotor wake is sheared by the non-uniformities in the horizontal velocity distributions, which are a direct result of the “discontinuities” in the trajectories of the stator wake. This shearing creates a kink in the trajectory of the rotor wake, a quadruple structure in the distribution of strain, regions with concentrated vorticity, high turbulence levels and high shear stresses, the latter with a complex structure that resembles the mean strain. Although the “hot spots” diffuse as they are advected downstream, they still have elevated turbulence levels compared to the local levels around them. In fact, every region of wake intersection has an elevated turbulence level.


2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Ayush Saraswat ◽  
Subhra Shankha Koley ◽  
Joseph Katz

Abstract Ongoing experiments conducted in a one-and-half stages axial compressor installed in the JHU refractive index-matched facility investigate the evolution of flow structure across blade rows. After previously focusing only on the rotor tip region, the present stereo-PIV (SPIV) measurements are performed in a series of axial planes covering an entire passage across the machine, including upstream of the IGV, IGV-rotor gap, rotor-stator gap, and downstream of the stator. The measurements are performed at flow rates corresponding to pre-stall condition and best efficiency point (BEP). Data are acquired for various rotor-blade orientations relative to the IGV and stator blades. The results show that at BEP, the wakes of IGV and rotor are much more distinct and the wake signatures of one row persists downstream of the next, e.g., the flow downstream of the stator is strongly affected by the rotor orientation. In contrast, under pre-stall conditions, the rotor orientation has minimal effect on the flow structure downstream of the stator. However, the wakes of the stator blades, where the axial momentum is low, are now wider. For both conditions, the flow downstream of the rotor is characterized by two regions of axial momentum deficit in addition to the rotor wake. A deficit on the pressure side of the rotor wake tip is associated with the tip leakage vortex (TLV) of the previous rotor blade, and is much broader at pre-stall condition. A deficit on the suction side of the rotor wake near the hub appears to be associated with the hub vortex generated by the neighboring blade, and is broader at BEP. At pre-stall, while the axial momentum upstream of the rotor decreases over the entire tip region, it is particularly evident near the rotor blade tip, where the instantaneous axial velocity becomes intermittently negative. Downstream of the rotor, there is a substantial reduction in mean axial momentum in the upper half of the passage, concurrently with an increase in the circumferential velocity. Consequently, the incidence angle upstream of the stator increases in certain regions by up to 30 degrees. These observations suggest that while the onset of the stall originates from the rotor tip flow, one must examine its impact on the flow structure in the stator passage as well.


Author(s):  
Martin Lipfert ◽  
Jan Habermann ◽  
Martin G. Rose ◽  
Stephan Staudacher ◽  
Yavuz Guendogdu

In a joint project between the Institute of Aircraft Propulsion Systems (ILA) and MTU Aero Engines a two-stage low pressure turbine is tested at design and strong off-design conditions. The experimental data taken in the altitude test-facility aims to study the effect of positive and negative incidence of the second stator vane. A detailed insight and understanding of the blade row interactions at these regimes is sought. Steady and time-resolved pressure measurements on the airfoil as well as inlet and outlet hot-film traverses at identical Reynolds number are performed for the midspan streamline. The results are compared with unsteady multi-stage CFD predictions. Simulations agree well with the experimental data and allow detailed insights in the time-resolved flow-field. Airfoil pressure field responses are found to increase with positve incidence whereas at negative incidence the magnitude remains unchanged. Different pressure to suction side phasing is observed for the studied regimes. The assessment of unsteady blade forces reveals that changes in unsteady lift are minor compared to changes in axial force components. These increase with increasing positive incidence. The wake-interactions are predominating the blade responses in all regimes. For the positive incidence conditions vane 1 passage vortex fluid is involved in the midspan passage interaction leading to a more distorted three-dimensional flow field.


2019 ◽  
Vol 141 (12) ◽  
Author(s):  
Wei Du ◽  
Lei Luo ◽  
Songtao Wang ◽  
Jian Liu ◽  
Bengt Sunden

Abstract Heat transfer characteristics in a latticework duct with various sidewalls are numerically investigated. The crossing angle is 90 deg and the number of subchannels is eleven on both the pressure side and suction side for each latticework duct. The thickness of the ribs is 8 mm and the distance between adjacent ribs is 24 mm. The investigation is conducted for various Reynolds numbers (11,000 to 55,000) and six different sidewalls. Flow structure, pressure drop, and heat transfer characteristics are analyzed. Results revealed that the sidewall has significant effects on heat transfer and flow structure. The triangle-shaped sidewall provides the highest Nusselt number accompanied by the highest friction factor. The sidewall with a slot shows the lowest friction factor and Nusselt number. An increased slot width decreased the Nusselt number and friction factor simultaneously.


Author(s):  
Chunill Hah

The primary focus of this paper is to investigate the loss sources in an advanced GE transonic compressor design with high reaction and high stage loading. This advanced compressor has been investigated both experimentally and analytically in the past. The measured compressor efficiency is significantly lower than the efficiency calculated with various existing tools based on RANS and URANS. The general understanding is that some important flow physics in this modern compressor design are not represented in the current tools. To pinpoint the source of the efficiency miss, an advanced test with detailed flow traverse was performed for the front one and a half stage at the NASA Glenn Research Center. In the present paper, a Large Eddy Simulation (LES) is employed to determine whether a higher-fidelity simulation can pick up any additional flow physics that can explain past efficiency miss with RANS and URANS. The results from the Large Eddy Simulation were compared with the NASA test results and the GE interpretation of the test data. LES calculates lower total pressure and higher total temperature on the pressure side of the stator, resulting in large loss generation on the pressure side of the stator. On the other hand, existing tools based on the RANS and URANS do not calculate this high total temperature and low total pressure on the pressure side of the stator. The calculated loss through the stator from LES seems to match the measured data and the GE data interpretation. Detailed examination of the unsteady flow field from LES indicates that the accumulation of high loss near the pressure side of the stator is due to the interaction of the rotor wake with the stator blade. The strong rotor wake interacts quite differently with the pressure side of the stator than with the suction side of the stator blade. The concave curvature on the pressure side of the stator blade increases the mixing of the rotor wake with the pressure side boundary layer significantly. On the other hand, the convex curvature on the suction side of the stator blade decreases the mixing and the suction side blade boundary layer remains thin. The jet velocity in the rotor wake in the stator frame seems to magnify the curvature effect in addition to inviscid redistribution of wake fluid toward the pressure side of the blade.


2005 ◽  
Vol 128 (1) ◽  
pp. 82-95 ◽  
Author(s):  
Francesco Soranna ◽  
Yi-Chih Chow ◽  
Oguz Uzol ◽  
Joseph Katz

The flow structure and turbulence around the leading and trailing edges of a rotor blade operating downstream of a row of inlet guide vanes (IGV) are investigated experimentally. Particle image velocimetry (PIV) measurements are performed in a refractive index matched facility that provides unobstructed view of the entire flow field. Data obtained at several rotor blade phases focus on modification to the flow structure and turbulence in the IGV wake as it propagates along the blade. The phase-averaged velocity distributions demonstrate that wake impingement significantly modifies the wall-parallel velocity component and its gradients along the blade. Due to spatially non-uniform velocity distribution, especially on the suction side, the wake deforms while propagating along the blade, expanding near the leading edge and shrinking near the trailing edge. While being exposed to the nonuniform strain field within the rotor passage, the turbulence within the IGV wake becomes spatially nonuniform and highly anisotropic. Several mechanisms, which are consistent with rapid distortion theory (RDT) and distribution of turbulence production rate, contribute to the observed trends. For example, streamwise (in rotor frame reference) diffusion in the aft part of the rotor passage enhances the streamwise fluctuations. Compression also enhances the turbulence production very near the leading edge. However, along the suction side, rapid changes to the direction of compression and extension cause negative production. The so-called wall blockage effect reduces the wall-normal component.


Author(s):  
Francesco Soranna ◽  
Yi-Chih Chow ◽  
Oguz Uzol ◽  
Joseph Katz

The flow structure and turbulence around the leading and trailing edges of a rotor blade operating downstream of a row of Inlet Guide Vanes (IGV) are investigated experimentally. Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) measurements are performed in a refractive index matched facility that provides unobstructed view of the entire flow field. Data obtained at several rotor blade phases focus on modification to the flow structure and turbulence in the IGV wake as it propagates along the blade. The phase-averaged velocity distributions demonstrate that wake impingement significantly modifies the wall-parallel velocity component and its gradients along the blade. Due to spatially non-uniform velocity distribution, especially on the suction side, the wake deforms while propagating along the blade, expanding near the leading edge and shrinking near the trailing edge. While being exposed to the non-uniform strain field within the rotor passage, the turbulence within the IGV wake becomes spatially non-uniform and highly anisotropic. Several mechanisms, which are consistent with rapid distortion theory (RDT) and distribution of turbulence production rate, contribute to the observed trends. For example, streamwise (in rotor frame reference) diffusion in the aft part of the rotor passage enhances the streamwise fluctuations. Compression also enhances the turbulence production very near the leading edge. However, along the suction side, rapid changes to the direction of compression and extension cause negative production. The so-called wall blockage effect reduces the wall-normal component.


Author(s):  
Adel Ghenaiet

Modern gas turbines operate in severe dusty environments, and because of such harsh operating conditions, their blades experience significant degradation in service. This paper presents a numerical study of particle dynamics and erosion in an hp axial turbine stage. The flow field is solved separately from the solid phase and constitutes the necessary data in the particle trajectories simulations using a Lagrangian tracking model based on the finite element method. Several parameters consider a statistical description such as particle size, shape and rebound, in addition to the turbulence effect. A semi empirical erosion correlation is used to estimate erosion contours and blades deteriorations, knowing the locations and conditions of impacts. The trajectory and erosion results show high erosion rates over the pressure side of NGV near trailing edge, in addition to extreme erosion observed toward the root corner, due to high number of particles impacting with high velocities. On the suction side, erosion is mainly over a narrow strip from leading edge. Erosion in the rotor blade is shown along the leading edge and spreading over the fore of the blade suction side, owing to a flux of particles entering at high velocities and incidence. On the pressure side, regions of dense erosion are observed near the leading edge and trailing edge as well as the tip corner. Critical erosion spots seen over NGV and rotor blade are signs of a premature failure.


1992 ◽  
Vol 114 (3) ◽  
pp. 668-674 ◽  
Author(s):  
I. N. Moyle ◽  
G. J. Walker ◽  
R. P. Shreeve

This paper describes the effect of tip clearance changes on the pressure at the case wall of a second-stage rotor. Wall shear distributions under the rotor tip are also presented. The results show low-pressure areas extending along the rotor suction side but lying away from the blade. Pressure contours indicate the tangential loading at the tip is lower than predicted by two-dimensional calculations; however, the predicted loading is observed between the lowest pressure’s path in the passage and the blade pressure side. The results suggest that a viscous or shearing layer, due to blade-to-wall relative motion, is generated on the blade side of the tip gap, which modifies the inviscid relative flow field and produces an unloading on the blade tip.


Author(s):  
Sungho Yoon ◽  
Rao Ajay ◽  
Venkata Chaluvadi ◽  
Vittorio Michelassi ◽  
Ramakrishna Mallina

Abstract The operability of the axial compressor is generally limited by endwall flows; either at the casing mainly due to the tip leakage flows or at the hub mainly due to three-dimensional corner separations. Therefore, it is crucial to improve flows near the endwalls to enhance the operability of the compressor. Based on a last-stage with cantilevered stator vanes, a small endwall slot was introduced to a rotor blade to mitigate the hub corner separation and maximize the aerodynamic operating range of axial compressors by natural aspiration. The developed flow control technology is numerically analyzed based on the in-house High-Speed Research Compressor (HSRC) which, in turn, represents the rear stage of a modern compressor. This compressor was predicted to stall due to hub corner separation on a rotor blade based on multistage CFD analysis. A small spanwise endwall slot, connecting the pressure side and the suction side of a compressor rotor blade, was introduced near the hub to provide the by-pass flows from the pressure side to the suction side (see Figure 1). This naturally-aspirated jet significantly reduced the three-dimensional corner separation which generally occurs where the suction side meets the hub. The substantial reduction of the three-dimensional corner separation, in turn, improved the aerodynamic stall margin of the compressor. The benefit is accomplished because the low momentum region near the hub was energized due to the naturally-aspirated jet through the endwall slot and the radial migration of the low momentum flow on the suction side was significantly reduced. A systematic parametric study was conducted to better understand the flow details and optimize the flow control without sacrificing aerodynamic efficiency. It was discovered that a very small slot, smaller than 10% of span, located near the endwall, was sufficient to have a more than 6% improvement of the stall margin with a negligible efficiency penalty (less than 0.1%). The naturally-aspirated flow through the small slot eliminates the source of the corner separation at the hub platform by strengthening the flow near the hub. This, in turn, reduces the overall aerodynamic blockage by decreasing the radial migration of the low momentum flow over a third of the span. Finally, evaluations of the mechanical strength and structural dynamics of slotted rotor blades, as well as the aerodynamic impact in a multi-stage environment were conducted and its results were discussed.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document