An Assessment of Uncertainty in Design Factors and Strain-Rate Inputs for Environmentally-Assisted Fatigue and Related Margins

2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Yogendra Garud
Author(s):  
Y. S. Garud

Abstract In the case of ASME Class 1 pressure vessels and piping code, as in other similar codes, the design adequacy for fatigue is based on the cumulative usage factor (CUF), with recent augmentation to account for possible environmental effects. This deterministic quantification utilizes several engineering parameters (inputs) and (multiplicative) empirical factors. Although the fixed values of some of these design factors and S–N curves are based on underlying experimental data, the associated uncertainties are not explicit in the resulting fatigue assessment that is effectively based on the singular, calculated quantities of CUF and Fen, projected for a specified service. As such, the resulting fatigue margin and associated conservatism remain implicit or inconsistent and unquantifiable. At the same time, there is an increased demand for either extending the life of existing systems or for new systems with economically viable or better optimized fatigue designs. One approach to address this is to use a more realistic evaluation offered by probabilistic techniques that take into account the various uncertainties. Such an approach to supplement the deterministic analysis was recently proposed by the author keeping the existing and familiar framework of CUF based assessment, while satisfying acceptable component reliability to meet the fatigue design adequacy. The CUF formulation includes an explicit consideration of the k-factors (for material, loading history, surface and size effects) as adjustments to the S–N data. The objective of this paper is to assess the impact of k-factors and their uncertainty on the failure probability and on the number of load-cycles for specified target reliability. Also, similar assessment is made for the impact of strain-rate variable and its uncertainty on the allowable load-cycles. This is illustrated with a typical application of the CUF analysis of a safety injection nozzle safe-end. The approach taken consists of parametric analysis of the CUF-based probability of failure by individually removing the factors and/or their uncertainty, and comparing the results with the base case where all factors and associated uncertainties are maintained at their original values. Results of this analysis and their implications are discussed, along with a generally applicable relation between the deterministic CUF and the probability of failure.


Author(s):  
S. M. L. Sastry

Ti3Al is an ordered intermetallic compound having the DO19-type superlattice structure. The compound exhibits very limited ductility in tension below 700°C because of a pronounced planarity of slip and the absence of a sufficient number of independent slip systems. Significant differences in slip behavior in the compound as a result of differences in strain rate and mode of deformation are reported here.Figure 1 is a comparison of dislocation substructures in polycrystalline Ti3Al specimens deformed in tension, creep, and fatigue. Slip activity on both the basal and prism planes is observed for each mode of deformation. The dominant slip vector in unidirectional deformation is the a-type (b) = <1120>) (Fig. la). The dislocations are straight, occur for the most part in a screw orientation, and are arranged in planar bands. In contrast, the dislocation distribution in specimens crept at 700°C (Fig. lb) is characterized by a much reduced planarity of slip, a tangled dislocation arrangement instead of planar bands, and an increased incidence of nonbasal slip vectors.


Author(s):  
F. Louchet ◽  
L.P. Kubin

Investigation of frictional forces -Experimental techniques and working conditions in the high voltage electron microscope have already been described (1). Care has been taken in order to minimize both surface and radiation effects under deformation conditions.Dislocation densities and velocities are measured on the records of the deformation. It can be noticed that mobile dislocation densities can be far below the total dislocation density in the operative system. The local strain-rate can be deduced from these measurements. The local flow stresses are deduced from the curvature radii of the dislocations when the local strain-rate reaches the values of ∿ 10-4 s-1.For a straight screw segment of length L moving by double-kink nucleation between two pinning points, the velocity is :where ΔG(τ) is the activation energy and lc the critical length for double-kink nucleation. The term L/lc takes into account the number of simultaneous attempts for double-kink nucleation on the dislocation line.


Author(s):  
C. W. Price

Little evidence exists on the interaction of individual dislocations with recrystallized grain boundaries, primarily because of the severely overlapping contrast of the high dislocation density usually present during recrystallization. Interesting evidence of such interaction, Fig. 1, was discovered during examination of some old work on the hot deformation of Al-4.64 Cu. The specimen was deformed in a programmable thermomechanical instrument at 527 C and a strain rate of 25 cm/cm/s to a strain of 0.7. Static recrystallization occurred during a post anneal of 23 s also at 527 C. The figure shows evidence of dissociation of a subboundary at an intersection with a recrystallized high-angle grain boundary. At least one set of dislocations appears to be out of contrast in Fig. 1, and a grainboundary precipitate also is visible. Unfortunately, only subgrain sizes were of interest at the time the micrograph was recorded, and no attempt was made to analyze the dislocation structure.


Author(s):  
D. S. Pritchard

The effect of varying the strain rate loading conditions in compression on a copper single crystal dispersion-hardened with SiO2 particles has been examined. These particles appear as small spherical inclusions in the copper lattice and have a volume fraction of 0.6%. The structure of representative crystals was examined prior to any testing on a transmission electron microscope (TEM) to determine the nature of the dislocations initially present in the tested crystals. Only a few scattered edge and screw dislocations were viewed in those specimens.


Author(s):  
M. F. Stevens ◽  
P. S. Follansbee

The strain rate sensitivity of a variety of materials is known to increase rapidly at strain rates exceeding ∼103 sec-1. This transition has most often in the past been attributed to a transition from thermally activated guide to viscous drag control. An important condition for imposition of dislocation drag effects is that the applied stress, σ, must be on the order of or greater than the threshold stress, which is the flow stress at OK. From Fig. 1, it can be seen for OFE Cu that the ratio of the applied stress to threshold stress remains constant even at strain rates as high as 104 sec-1 suggesting that there is not a mechanism transition but that the intrinsic strength is increasing, since the threshold strength is a mechanical measure of intrinsic strength. These measurements were made at constant strain levels of 0.2, wnich is not a guarantee of constant microstructure. The increase in threshold stress at higher strain rates is a strong indication that the microstructural evolution is a function of strain rate and that the dependence becomes stronger at high strain rates.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document