Ecological theory suggests that along productivity gradients, abundances of organisms within trophic levels will increase in a stepwise pattern from producers to consumers. To test this theory I investigated changes in abundance of soil arthropods at three trophic levels: microphytophages, represented by Collembola, predacious mites (Acari) that feed on Collembola, and three groups of macroarthropods (spiders, ants, and centipedes) that were observed to feed on mites. Changes in abundance were monitored along a gradient in vegetation structure from grass to shrub to forest in the Canadian prairies. I controlled for temporal variation in abundance among years and surveys within a year. As predicted, (i) numbers of Collembola did not change with increases in productivity; (ii) mite numbers were greatest in the shrublands; and (iii) numbers of macroarthropod predators increased from grassland to shrubland, and there was a nonsignificant increase in numbers of spiders and centipedes in forest habitat. Contrary to predictions, macroarthropod numbers were not significantly greater in forest habitat, and ant numbers actually declined. Possible explanations for the lack of increase in macroarthropod predator abundance in the forest habitat with the greatest productivity include decreased ground-level humidity and greater abundance of macroarthropod predators and parasites in forest environments.
Competition components along productivity gradients – revisiting a classic dispute in ecology