Mutation of sequences flanking and separating transcription factor binding sites in a Drosophila enhancer significantly alter its output

Here we explore how mutating different sequences in an enhancer that regulates patterned gene expression in Drosophila melanogaster embryos can affect its output. We used quantitative imaging to analyze the effects of a wide variety of mutations in the hunchback distal anterior enhancer. This enhancer has been shown to respond to the anterior morphogen Bicoid, but we found that mutations in only one of the five strong Bicoid sites in the enhancer has a significant effect on its binding. The pioneer factor Zelda, which binds to this enhancer and is the only other factor implicated in its activity besides Bicoid. However, we found that mutations of all its sites only has modest effect that is limited to reduction of its output in more posterior regions of the embryo, where Bicoid levels are low. In contrast to the modest effects of mutating known transcription factor binding sites, randomizing the sequences between Zelda and Bicoid sites significantly compromised enhancer activity. Finer mapping suggested that the sequences that determine activity are broadly distributed in the enhancer. Mutations in short sequences flanking Bicoid binding sites have stronger effects than mutations to Bicoid sites themselves, highlighting the complex and counterintuitive nature of the relationship between enhancer sequence and activity.