Alternative stable states in the aquatic vegetation of shallow urban lakes. II. Catastrophic loss of aquatic plants consequent to nutrient enrichment

The theory of alternative stable states predicts that high nutrient concentrations increase the probability of shallow lakes switching from a state dominated by vascular macrophytes to one dominated by phytoplankton and/or other algae. In the first paper of this series it was demonstrated that chronic, low-level nutrient loading did not affect a switch across vegetation states. To test the possibility that higher nutrient loadings result in vegetation changes, replicated mesocosms (~3000 L) were placed in an urban lake densely colonized by Vallisneria americana Michaux, a submerged angiosperm, and were subjected to higher levels of chronic nutrient enrichment. Moderate and high nutrient loadings significantly increased phytoplankton biomass and produced extensive, dense mats of floating algae. Many mesocosms became covered by the floating fern Azolla pinnata R.Br. This reduced light penetration and concentrations of dissolved oxygen in the water column profoundly and resulted in the complete loss of V. americana from almost all nutrient-enriched mesocosms within 4 months. A catastrophic loss of submerged aquatic plants so rapidly after nutrient enrichment is a relatively novel experimental finding, particularly in terms of the likely mechanism; that is, shading and subsequent anoxia caused by dense mats of floating plants other than algae.